Small Town Murder Podcast
Tour

SHUT UP AND GIVE ME MURDER!—The Hit Podcast Goes Live

Learn More Buy Tickets

Your independent guide to the best entertainment in 2026! This website is operated by a ticket broker.
Ticket prices are set by third-party sellers and may be above or below face value.
We are not affiliated with nor endorsed by Small Town Murder Podcast.

Small Town Murder Podcast Goes Live Across America

Small Town Murder, the hit true crime comedy podcast, is taking its darkly hilarious live show on the road throughout 2025 and 2026. Hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman are bringing their signature blend of meticulous research, horrible tragedy, and comedic spin to theaters and venues across the country.

What Is Small Town Murder?

Small Town Murder is a weekly podcast where comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman examine a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. Since launching in 2017, the show has grown into a phenomenon with over 600 episodes and a devoted fanbase who embrace the duo's catchphrase: "Shut up and give me murder!"

What sets Small Town Murder apart is its unique approach: in-depth research presented with dark comedic relief. James and Jimmie aren't just reading headlines—they dig deep into each case, exploring the community, the victims, the perpetrators, and the bizarre details that make each story unforgettable.

Who Are James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman?

James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman are Phoenix-based stand-up comedians and longtime best friends who met while opening for fellow comedian Jim Jeffries. They bonded over their shared love of true crime and mutual experiences with tragedy, leading them to create Crime in Sports in 2016 and Small Town Murder in 2017.

Beyond podcasting, both continue performing stand-up comedy. James is also a filmmaker, bringing visual storytelling expertise to the podcast's narrative approach. Their chemistry and comedic timing have earned them a cult following that continues to grow.

The Live Experience

The Small Town Murder live tour preserves the spirit of the podcast while adding the energy of a live audience. Shows typically run around two hours and feature James's stand-up comedy opener followed by a full episode presentation with all the research, jokes, and audience interaction that fans love. It's like watching the podcast being recorded—but with thousands of fellow "scumbags" sharing the experience.

Get Your Small Town Murder Tickets

BigStub connects fans with verified sellers offering authentic Small Town Murder tickets at competitive, all-in prices. No hidden fees, secure transactions, and 20+ years of trusted ticket marketplace experience.

Complete Guide: Small Town Murder Live 2025-2026

Upcoming Tour Dates

  • December 12, 2025 – Philadelphia, PA @ The Fillmore
  • February 21, 2026 – Nashville, TN @ The Fisher Center for the Performing Arts
  • March 6, 2026 – Durham, NC @ Carolina Theatre
  • March 7, 2026 – Atlanta, GA @ The Tabernacle
  • May 1, 2026 – Salt Lake City, UT @ The Depot
  • May 2, 2026 – Denver, CO @ Paramount Theatre
  • May 29, 2026 – Buffalo, NY @ Asbury Hall at Babeville
  • May 30, 2026 – Royal Oak, MI @ Royal Oak Music Theatre
  • September 18, 2026 – Milwaukee, WI @ Pabst Theater
  • September 19, 2026 – Minneapolis, MN @ State Theatre
  • October 3, 2026 – Dallas, TX @ Majestic Theatre
  • October 16, 2026 – San Jose, CA @ California Theatre
  • October 17, 2026 – Sacramento, CA @ Channel 24
  • November 13, 2026 – Tarrytown, NY @ Tarrytown Music Hall
  • November 14, 2026 – Medford, MA @ Chevalier Theatre

How to Purchase Small Town Murder Tickets

  1. Browse upcoming shows in the ticket listings above
  2. Select your city and date—shows sell out quickly
  3. Choose your seats—orchestra, balcony, or VIP when available
  4. Review all-in pricing—no hidden fees at checkout
  5. Complete secure purchase with buyer protection guarantee
  6. Receive tickets via email or mobile transfer

About the Podcasts

Small Town Murder

Launched in 2017, Small Town Murder releases new episodes every Thursday (plus bonus Wednesday and Friday episodes for Patreon supporters). Each episode runs approximately two hours and covers a single case from a small American town.

Crime in Sports

Crime in Sports launched in 2016 and examines athletes who committed crimes. It was James and Jimmie's first podcast and established their unique true crime comedy format.

Your Stupid Opinions

Launched in 2023, Your Stupid Opinions explores the wild world of internet reviews. New episodes release every Monday.

What to Expect at a Live Show

  • Stand-up comedy opener from James Pietragallo
  • Full podcast episode with all the research and jokes
  • Audience interaction and energy
  • Merchandise available for purchase
  • Meet-and-greet/VIP packages at select shows
  • Runtime: Approximately 2 hours

The "Asshole" Philosophy

James and Jimmie famously describe themselves as "assholes, not scumbags"—meaning they'll make jokes about terrible situations, but they never mock victims or make light of genuine tragedy. This philosophy has earned them respect from true crime fans who appreciate dark humor with clear ethical boundaries.

Follow Small Town Murder

Frequently Asked Questions: Small Town Murder Live

What is Small Town Murder?

Small Town Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman. Each week they examine a small town, explore what makes it tick, and cover a murder that took place there with in-depth research and dark comedic commentary.

Who are the hosts of Small Town Murder?

James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman are Phoenix-based stand-up comedians and longtime friends who host Small Town Murder, Crime in Sports, and Your Stupid Opinions. They met while opening for comedian Jim Jeffries.

How long is a Small Town Murder live show?

Live shows typically run approximately two hours, including James's stand-up comedy opener and a full podcast episode presentation. Doors usually open two hours before showtime.

What happens at a Small Town Murder live show?

Shows feature stand-up comedy from James, a complete podcast episode with all the research and jokes, audience interaction, and the same chemistry and humor fans love from the podcast. Merchandise is available, and some shows offer VIP meet-and-greet packages.

Are there VIP packages available?

Yes, select Small Town Murder shows offer VIP and meet-and-greet packages that include premium seating and opportunities to meet James and Jimmie. Availability varies by venue.

How much are Small Town Murder tickets?

Ticket prices vary by venue, seating section, and demand. General admission typically ranges from standard theater pricing to premium VIP packages. Verified resale platforms show all-in pricing with no hidden fees.

Is Small Town Murder appropriate for all ages?

Small Town Murder contains explicit content discussing murder, violence, and adult themes with mature language. Shows are recommended for adult audiences only and are not suitable for children.

How often do James and Jimmie tour?

Small Town Murder tours regularly throughout the year with dates added frequently. The duo performs live shows while continuing to record weekly podcast episodes.

What is Crime in Sports?

Crime in Sports is James and Jimmie's original podcast launched in 2016. It examines athletes who committed crimes, using the same true crime comedy format that made Small Town Murder successful.

How can I get ad-free episodes?

Ad-free episodes of Small Town Murder, Crime in Sports, and Your Stupid Opinions are available for Patreon subscribers at $5/month and above at patreon.com/crimeinsports.

What does "Shut up and give me murder" mean?

It's the podcast's signature catchphrase, often shouted by fans at live shows. It represents the audience's enthusiasm for the hosts to get past introductions and dive into the week's murder case.

Are James and Jimmie actually from small towns?

Both hosts are based in Phoenix, Arizona, but Small Town Murder covers cases from small towns across America. The hosts have researched over 600 different small communities for the podcast.

Can I request a town for the podcast?

James and Jimmie select cases based on their own research, but fans often suggest towns through social media. The hosts have covered towns from every region of the United States.

What should I wear to a Small Town Murder show?

Dress casually and comfortably. Many fans wear Small Town Murder merchandise or true crime-themed apparel, but there's no dress code for live shows.

Will there be merchandise at live shows?

Yes, official Small Town Murder merchandise is typically available for purchase at live shows, including t-shirts, hoodies, and other items. Arrive early for the best selection.

Powered by BigStub® - Trusted Everywhere

Trustpilot

Your independent guide to the best entertainment in 2026! This website is operated by a ticket broker. Tickets are listed by third-party sellers and may be above face value.

Get your tickets now!